What is physical education?


What did research say about effective physical education

A few years ago - 2023- we undertook a review on physical education (PE) literature for a school system. That review had two parts 1. looked at the history of purpose of PE in Australia and 2. a scoping review of international literature focussed on the question - What are teachers being told about how to teach PE? The review revealed a clear message: the most effective PE lessons are designed around active learning, student decision-making, social interaction, and meaningful engagement with movement.

The need for a Big Shift in Physical Education

For decades, PE has often been characterised by a "demonstrate-practice-repeat" approach, typically linked to a behavourist paradigm and to student reproduction of behaviour modelled by the teacher by teacher-led demonstrations. While direct instruction has a place in learning in physical education, the evidence suggests it is insufficient on its own for achieving the broad aims of PE across physical, social-emotional and cognitive domains of learning.

Today's expectations for PE are broad. Curricula ask for students who are physically competent, socially capable, emotionally intelligent, and motivated to remain active throughout life. Research consistently shows that achieving these outcomes requires a wide range or spectrum of teaching styles.

One of the strongest findings from the review was that curriculum and pedagogical models help teachers to understand how to structure teaching to meet a framework for curriculum, pedagogy, assessment, and learning experiences.

Three models stood out as having the strongest evidence base:

1.      Sport Education Curriculum Model

Here, Sport Education is considered a curriculum model as it provides a macro structure for representative design of sport and physical activity as it occurs in clubs and community settings to be reproduced in physical education.

Sport Education was the most researched model in the review. Across dozens of studies, it was associated with:

  • Higher student motivation
  • Greater autonomy and responsibility
  • Improved social relationships
  • Better game performance and tactical understanding
  • Increased physical activity levels
  • Stronger emotional and social development 

Perhaps most importantly, students often reported feeling more included, valued, and engaged than in traditional PE programs. Teachers also described the model as professionally rewarding and pedagogically refreshing.

*The next two models are considered pedagogical models as they are typically used for specific learning objectives.

2. Cooperative Learning

Cooperative Learning shifts the focus from individual performance to learning with and through others.

Research found improvements in:

  • Social and emotional skills
  • Communication
  • Leadership
  • Empathy
  • Motivation
  • Cognitive learning outcomes
  • Rather than competing against classmates, students collaborate to achieve shared goals, creating richer learning experiences and stronger classroom relationships.

3. Teaching for Understanding: A game-based approach

Game-based approaches (GBAs) place tactical thinking at the centre of learning. Instead of learning skills as prescribed techniques in isolation from the play before playing games, students develop understanding through intentionally purposeful game situations. Research links GBAs with:

  • Improved decision-making
  • Greater tactical knowledge
  • Increased enjoyment
  • Higher motivation
  • Enhanced game performance

The pedagogical model helps students learn the "why" before the "how", producing more thoughtful and engaged participants. Variations of GBAs in Australia include the Game Sense approach (Australian Sports Commission, 1996), Play Practice (Alan Launder, 2001), Play with Purpose (Pill, 2007), and Grammar of Games (Forrest, 2015).

The Real Lesson from the review: Teaching PE Is About Creating Learning Possibilities

A particularly important theme running through the review is that effective PE teaching is not about selecting one "best" model or within a model one teaching style. Rather, quality teaching involves matching teaching approaches to learning goals, student needs, and contextual factors. This means:

  • Planning for multiple learning outcomes
  • Using a range of teaching styles
  • Providing opportunities for student voice and choice
  • Balancing teacher guidance with learner autonomy
  • Adapting pedagogy to suit learners and contexts

Why This Matters for Schools

The review offers a particularly insightful perspective on the Australian context. Australian teachers already have mandated curricula that tell them what students should learn. The challenge is often how to teach in ways that help students achieve those outcomes. The evidence suggests that teaching styles, instructional models, and pedagogy mobility are critical pedagogical and curriculum knowledge in bridging this gap. The literature encourages the idea that PE teachers need to draw from a broad pedagogical toolkit, selecting approaches that support physical, cognitive, emotional, and social development simultaneously.

Summary of What PE Teachers Are Being Told

If there is one overarching message from the research we did, it is this:

Effective physical education develops more than physical skills, but education in movement for movement ability is core or central to the puropse of PE.

The strongest evidence supports approaches that build motivated, autonomous, socially capable, and physically competent learners. In the empirical literature, models such as Sport Education, Cooperative Learning, GBA, and Teaching Personal and Social Responsibility consistently outperform traditional approaches when broader educational outcomes are considered.

PE is not simply about getting students moving. It is about creating meaningful learning experiences through movement. When teachers design lessons that develop thinking, collaboration, responsibility, and enjoyment alongside physical competence, PE becomes a subject that can genuinely influence lifelong engagement in physical activity.

Key Takeaway

The question is no longer "How do we teach physical education?"

The large body of research we have on physical education curriculum and pedagogy invites a much more powerful question:

"How do we design physical education experiences that help young people learn, grow, connect, and choose active lives?

________________________________________________________________________________

This blog is developed from the report: 

AISNSW PDHPE Literature reviews: Reports and Recommendations

https://researchnow.flinders.edu.au/en/publications/aisnsw-pdhpe-literature-reviews-reports-and-recommendations/

________________________________________________________________________________

Thanks for stopping by and reading this post. If you would like to connect with me about a project to do with this blog or any of the other ideas that I have blogged about, you can contact me by the email link available here 

Related blogs

What are physical education teachers being told about how to teach sport? here

Reflections on meaningful physical education here

Physical education: a wicked problem here
Physical education as praxis here
Physical education: contested ground here
How do we design our PE programs here

Comments

Popular Posts